Innovative Solutions for Personal & Business Insurance

Our presence in the great city of Plymouth started on December 7, 1950 as Flanagan Insurance. Founded in the heart of the Kettle Moraine, our staff offers the extensive resources and services that The Benefit Companies continues to provide at all of our locations, not just one.

Tight integration with our Brookfield headquarters and Green Bay office ensures that all of the services offered at this location are also available through our service staff. We make use of our local connections and professional experience in order to stay in sync and constantly up to date.


Personal Insurance

We offer a full array of individual products and personal insurance that will protect your valuable assets and put your mind at ease.
Learn more >

Business Insurance

We stay in front of the issues that can impact your business. Let us help you design a risk management program that is rock solid.
Learn more >

Our Team

Our dedicated, experienced team will work closely with you to custom tailor an insurance program that addresses all of your needs.
Learn more >

Big i Trusted Choice Independent Insurance Agents Logo

Business Services

We’ll do more than just quote your insurance. Experience the difference between what is promised to you and what is actually delivered to you.
Learn more >